I've had both Forex Robotron and Odin Forex Robot Both failed miserably. Robotron would always start on a short or loosing trade as its set for long trades only. OK sometimes depending how the trade is going it would build up a small winning amount. But then sometimes it would go all the way down almost to the Stop loss, come all the way back up and stop at the trade start, making about 50 cents instead of carrying on up the chart the way the candle is going. Another time it would just follow the candle down to the stop loss.